Microsoft IE7’s abysmal interface
Usability and New Users and Technology | 8:18 am Sunday, Feb 25 2007 |
Why is it that Microsoft think they know what is good for ALL of their customers?
Take IE7. I can’t stand IE personally, but it’s on the machine that my mum and dad use. I only use IE when the occasional site falls apart dramatically in the Firefox browser (proving the site developer hasn’t even tested for Firefox, given the way the site breaks apart outside of IE). And then, if I can, I use the IE Tab extension/add-on in Firefox, rather than loading up IE7 on its own.
They were only introduced to computers in July 2006 when we gave them broadband and one of our old computers. The concept of computers is quite scary to them, given they’re both virtually in retirement. I recall demonstrating a webpage, talking about links — but forgetting to explain in detail — and dad wondered what a link was, or even how it was displayed, or what you did with it… all the basic things I’ve long forgotten to think about after 12 years of online experience!
So when IE7 came along, with Microsoft’s “we know what’s good for you” approach, the interface for web browsing was different — and there is no way to adjust it.
For instance, the menu bar no longer appears at the top of the screen. Usability thus drops — EVERY other program with a menu bar has it at the top of the window, so why does IE7 depart from standards? The address bar is now at the top and is not able to be moved.
And then there’s a line of cryptic icons for Favorites, tools etc — again, stuck in place at the bottom of the toolbars as a “command bar”. Sure, you can add text labels to some of the icons, but you cannot move this command bar anywhere. So, the links toolbar cannot be the bottom toolbar, just above the content window… Microsoft have decided that the very top address bar and the bottom Command bar are locked in place and cannot be changed.
Why not let users CHOOSE where those usability elements are placed, according to their preferences or their existing habits? It’s hard enough, especially for inexperienced users, that the interface is no longer quite the same (let alone a whole other post about changing to Tabbed browsing).
Why don’t Microsoft let their customers think for themselves? Instead of the old advertising tagline “where do you want to go today?” — perhaps Microsoft should have put “we’ll tell you where you’re going today, you don’t get a choice.”
